“All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” This famous George Orwell line was written as satire but has been accepted as a truism by many.
The latest contest in the equality game pits religious orientation versus sexual orientation. Last year, the New Mexico Supreme Court upheld the conviction of a Christian photographer convicted of violating the state's anti-discrimination law. As a matter of religious principle, Elaine Huguenin and her husband declined the request to photograph the commitment ceremony for a lesbian couple. The lesbian couple got another photographer and the Huguenins got the tab for thousands of dollars in court costs.
Influenced by events in New Mexico, the Arizona legislature this year passed SB1062 that was subsequently vetoed by their governor. The bill would have enhanced the ability to make business decisions based on religious convictions. Though issues of sexual orientation were not mentioned in the wording of the bill, nevertheless, it was framed by the national media as anti-gay legislation. Also, at times it was described as a “religious liberty” issue. Currently, there are numerous states that have proposed laws similar to the Arizona model.